A war foretold:how the CIA and MI6 got hold of Putin's Ukraine plans and why
4 days ago
- #Intelligence Failures
- #Russia-Ukraine War
- #Geopolitical Conflict
- William Burns, CIA director, warned Putin in November 2021 about disastrous consequences of invading Ukraine.
- Putin ignored warnings, focusing on perceived US threats and Russia's strategic vulnerability.
- US and UK intelligence accurately predicted Russia's invasion plans, but European allies were skeptical.
- Ukrainian President Zelenskyy dismissed invasion warnings, fearing economic panic over military preparation.
- Putin's decision to invade was likely made in early 2020, with preparations hidden from most of his inner circle.
- Detailed Russian war plans included attacks from multiple directions, including Belarus, and assassination attempts on Zelenskyy.
- European intelligence services, remembering the Iraq war intelligence failures, doubted the likelihood of a full-scale invasion.
- US and UK shared extensive intelligence with allies, but skepticism remained due to obscured sources and methods.
- Zelenskyy's last-minute realization of the invasion threat came too late for adequate preparation.
- The invasion began on February 24, 2022, with initial underestimations of Ukrainian resistance and overestimations of Russian military effectiveness.
- Zelenskyy's leadership during the invasion rallied Ukrainian society, despite earlier failures to heed warnings.
- Intelligence failures highlighted the danger of dismissing scenarios based on perceived rationality or impossibility.
- Post-invasion, European intelligence services reevaluated their approaches to worst-case scenarios.