Show HN: A light GPT-5 vs. Claude Code comparison
17 days ago
- #Markdown serialization
- #PR evaluation
- #Testability
- GPT's evaluation favors Charlie's PR for better testability and reliability despite Claude's better narrative and polish.
- Gemini highlights Claude's PR's critical lack of testability, especially in core scenarios, making Charlie's contribution more reliable.
- Charlie's PR includes meaningful unit tests for absolutizeImageUrls but misses edge cases and lacks integration tests.
- Charlie's PR description is clear but lacks detailed function names, file paths, and has placeholder text.
- Charlie's implementation is focused, minimal, and idiomatic, with minor nits like regex brittleness and unused parameters.
- Claude's PR lacks tests for new baseUrl behavior in markdown serialization, leaving core scenarios untested.
- Claude's PR description is clear but omits details like serializer API changes and specific markdown generation paths affected.
- Claude's implementation is focused and idiomatic but lacks baseUrl support in other Markdown serializers like ClipboardTextSerializer.