Assigning Open Problems in Class
9 days ago
- #open-problems
- #education
- #pedagogy
- Assigning open problems as extra credit involves deciding whether to inform students about the problem's open status.
- Telling students a problem is open can be fair but may discourage some; not telling can lead to unexpected solutions.
- Distinguishing between truly hard open problems and those simply unsolved by the instructor is important.
- Instructors may worry about students' perception if they solve a problem the instructor couldn't, but enthusiasm for the solution can mitigate this.
- Extra credit problems can either count towards the grade or only for recommendation letters, with arguments for both approaches.
- Students might prefer knowing a problem is open, and solving it could reflect luck or exposure to certain methods rather than instructor inadequacy.
- Partial approaches to unsolved problems can be assigned as sub-problems to guide students.