The Headlines Are Evil, and They're Bringing Us Down
a year ago
- #media
- #legal
- #tariffs
- The United States Court of Trade ruled against Trump's tariffs, but headlines misrepresented the scope of the decision.
- The court did not rule that the president can never impose tariffs, only that specific tariffs announced by Trump exceeded his authority.
- Headlines like 'Court says Trump doesn’t have the authority to set tariffs' are misleading and clickbait.
- The court's decision was based on the nondelegation doctrine, requiring Congress to set clear limits on presidential tariff powers.
- Trump's 'worldwide and retaliatory' tariffs were struck down for being too broad, while 'trafficking tariffs' lacked justification under the declared national emergency.
- The administration has appealed the decision, which may go to the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit and potentially the Supreme Court.
- Media outlets used sensational headlines to attract clicks, sometimes presenting the same story with different, misleading titles.