Why do so many students have ADHD?
4 months ago
- #mental_health
- #education
- #disability
- Increase in students claiming disabilities in UK universities from 8% in 2008 to 16% in 2023, with elite universities like Oxford and Cambridge seeing a rise from 5% to 20%.
- Most common disabilities include ADHD, anxiety, depression, and non-profound autism spectrum disorder (ASD).
- Two simplistic explanations for the rise: gaming the system for advantages, and better medical recognition of conditions.
- Philosophy of science perspective by Ian Hacking: 'looping effects' where diagnoses change behavior and vice versa, leading to evolving definitions of conditions like autism.
- Historical shift in autism diagnosis from severe impairment to a broad spectrum, including high-functioning individuals.
- Concept of 'making up people'—social roles like 'high-functioning autistic' or 'skater' emerge from cultural and medical recognition.
- Concerns that accommodations may hinder students from developing essential life skills like meeting deadlines and handling stress.
- University structures now heavily defer to medical diagnoses, limiting educators' ability to enforce discipline or tough love.
- Potential irony: well-intentioned support measures may be counterproductive, preventing students from facing necessary challenges.