Hasty Briefsbeta

Bilingual

Audit finds San Francisco tax official steered $10M contract to friend

5 hours ago
  • #corruption
  • #procurement
  • #audit
  • San Francisco's chief assistant treasurer improperly steered a $10 million tax management contract to Mechanical Orchard, a company led by her friends, creating a 'pay-to-play' appearance.
  • An independent audit confirmed she manipulated the procurement process, favoring Mechanical Orchard by tailoring the scope of work and withholding information from other bidders.
  • Shah's actions included undisclosed personal relationships with company executives and potential familial benefit, as her niece was hired by a subcontractor.
  • The audit criticized the treasurer's office for lax controls and lack of checks and balances, prompting organizational reforms.
  • Mechanical Orchard withdrew from the contract after media exposure, and Shah, placed on leave, later left city employment.