We Added a Console Notice to Internationalizationext – and Why We Removed It
9 hours ago
- #Community Feedback
- #Open Source Sustainability
- #Developer Experience
- i18next, celebrating 15 years, relies on its commercial product Locize for sustainability, as traditional open-source funding methods proved insufficient.
- In v25.8.0, a console.info notice about Locize was added to raise awareness among developers, with opt-out options, but faced backlash over developer experience and potential security incidents.
- Community feedback highlighted issues like log flooding and operational burdens, with a reported but unverified link to Google Safe Browsing blocks, leading to an apology and investigation.
- Data showed the console notice drove a small number of explicit signups (6.2%), but the overall impact was limited compared to community costs and friction.
- The notice will be removed in v26.0.0 due to high community and operational costs outweighing benefits, with support encouraged through trying Locize or spreading awareness.