Bcachefs Goes to "Externally Maintained"
12 days ago
- #linux-kernel
- #bcachefs
- #filesystems
- Bcachefs is moving to 'externally maintained' status, but immediate removal from the mainline kernel is not planned.
- Concerns exist about the code bit-rotting if further changes are not accepted into mainline, leaving users to rely on external trees.
- Kent Overstreet, the maintainer, emphasizes the importance of a stable release process and supporting users, which conflicts with kernel release schedules.
- Discussions suggest potential solutions like designating a proxy maintainer, but this role is seen as difficult and thankless.
- Quality concerns about Linux filesystem code are raised, with examples of ext4 bugs and lack of robust automatic testing.
- Some argue for complete removal of bcachefs from the mainline kernel to avoid leaving unmaintained code that could harm users.
- Alternative viewpoints suggest keeping the code in the kernel allows users to continue using it without patches, albeit without updates.