What’s so great about excellence? (1981)
a day ago
- #MacArthur Foundation
- #Meritocracy Debate
- #Philanthropy Critique
- The MacArthur Foundation announced the winners of its 'genius' grant, awarding $500,000 to 23 individuals across various fields.
- John D. MacArthur, the founder, amassed wealth through controversial means, later establishing the foundation with a focus on creative individuals.
- The foundation's Prize Fellows Program aims to support talented individuals, but critics argue it merely rewards those already successful and recognized.
- The selection process is seen as elitist, favoring established figures like Robert Penn Warren and Robert Coles, who already have numerous accolades.
- The article critiques the broader culture of awards and honors, questioning their societal value and fairness, especially in a democratic society.
- Examples like the Kennedy Center Honors and the Albert Einstein Peace Prize are cited as unnecessary, benefiting those already celebrated.
- The MacArthur program is contrasted with John D. MacArthur's self-made success, highlighting the irony of the foundation's credentialist approach.