How to Disagree
2 days ago
- The web has turned writing into a conversation, leading to more disagreement, especially measured by word count, not necessarily anger.
- A disagreement hierarchy is proposed, ranging from DH0 (name-calling) to DH6 (refuting the central point).
- Lower-level disagreements (DH0–DH2) are weak and often unconvincing, while higher levels (DH4–DH6) are more convincing but rarer.
- Understanding the hierarchy helps readers evaluate arguments and spot intellectual dishonesty, and encourages writers to engage at higher levels.
- Disagreeing well reduces meanness and improves conversations, making participants happier.